Here’s a bold statement: Fin Smith isn’t just another fly-half—he’s England’s number one and the key to unlocking their potential against New Zealand this Saturday. But here’s where it gets controversial: while George Ford started against Australia for leadership reasons, I’m arguing that Fin’s all-around brilliance, especially his defensive masterclass against Fiji, makes him the undeniable choice. Let me explain why.
Fin Smith’s performance against Fiji was nothing short of remarkable. His defensive display was arguably the best we’ve seen from an England fly-half in years. What stood out was his fearless tackling against a physically imposing Fijian side—a testament to his grit and determination. And this is the part most people miss: his game management was equally impressive. He seamlessly blended finesse with control, making decisive calls even when the first half wasn’t going England’s way. His ability to strategically calm the team and make big decisions under pressure is a skill he’s truly mastered.
At just 23, Fin is already a force to be reckoned with. Looking ahead, with George Ford both challenging and supporting him, I believe Fin will only grow stronger. But let’s not forget Marcus Smith, who’s also developing into a player with unique qualities. While he’s not yet the answer at full-back—a position that still needs a watertight solution—his potential to be an impactful bench player, à la Damian McKenzie for New Zealand, is undeniable. McKenzie’s decisive try against Scotland highlights the value of such players, and Marcus could fill that role if given the freedom to shine.
Here’s the controversial bit: While Ford’s leadership and continuity are valuable, Fin’s defensive prowess and all-around game make him the more complete player. His instincts under pressure—like the moment he pinned Fiji back with a strategic kick instead of going wide—are the kind of championship-winning plays that can’t be coached. Plus, having an aggressive fly-half like Fin eliminates the need to adjust the defensive system, giving England a tactical edge.
Of course, there’s a strong case for Ford starting and Fin coming off the bench. Behind-the-scenes factors will play a role, but whichever way the coaches go, New Zealand will face a serious challenge. Unlike past matchups, this time the All Blacks will be under real pressure, thanks to Fin’s ability to execute game-changing kicks like the 50-20.
So, here’s my question to you: Do you agree that Fin Smith is England’s number one fly-half, or do you think George Ford’s experience still gives him the edge? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments—this debate is far from over!
